Jump to content

Amazon sued for enrolling and charging customers into Audible without consent

From Consumer Rights Wiki

Audible, a subsidiary of Amazon, has been the subject of class action lawsuits alleging that it enrolled Amazon customers in Audible memberships without their knowledge or consent and charged them the $14.95 monthly subscription fee. One of the cases was dismissed with prejudice in July 2026, while the other remains pending[1][2][3]

Background

[edit | edit source]

In Sherk v. Audible, the plaintiff alleged Audible enrolled existing Amazon account holders into Audible's monthly subscription ("membership") without their knowledge or consent.[4][5] The complaint also alleged that Audible utilized payment information already on file with Amazon, charged monthly membership fees, and made it difficult for users to discover, cancel, or obtain refunds for these subscriptions.

In Heck v. Amazon, the plaintiff used Amazon’s "FREE No-Rush Shipping" option, which came with a "digital reward".[1] She later discovered that redeeming this reward resulted in her personal and payment information being passed to Audible. The lawsuit alleged that Audible then enrolled her in a 30-day trial that automatically converted into a paid subscription unless it was affirmatively canceled. The plaintiff alleged she never received notice, confirmation, or cancellation information and was billed for several months without knowledge.

Automatic enrollment and charges

[edit | edit source]

The plaintiff states that the victims of Amazon's enrollment in Audible had a difficult time cancelling the subscription service, which may be due to the company's failure to enact click-to-cancel[5] that can result in customers continuing to be charged for the service during the time it takes them to cancel.

A second lawsuit, Sherk v. Audible, was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington in March 2025, claiming that Amazon would pass consumer information to Audible, which would then sign up consumers for a free trial.[1] After the free trial expired, the consumer would be transitioned to a paid subscription without notification.

Corporate response

[edit | edit source]

Amazon and Audible responded to Heck's claims by arguing that they had no duty to disclose any link between "No-Rush Shipping" rewards and Audible enrollment, since the rewards were marketed as digital credits and any Audible trial was separate, voluntary, and disclosed.[6] They contended that Heck failed to show reliance or causation, as her choice of "No-Rush Shipping" was motivated by free shipping rather than Audible. It was further claimed they complied with the California Auto-Renewal Law by providing clear terms, obtaining consent, and sending acknowledgment e-mails, suggesting that Heck either ignored or forgot these notices. Drawing on Viveros v. Audible, they insisted that the signups were transparent and optional, meaning Heck must have given consent. Finally, they questioned whether she had suffered any real injury, noting that she had received both rewards and the Audible trial and could have canceled before charges accrued, making her losses the result of her own inaction rather than deception.

The court rejected most of these arguments at the dismissal stage.[6] It found that Heck plausibly alleged non-disclosure, lack of consent, and ARL violations, which were sufficient to proceed. Notably, the court noted that the situation was unlike Viveros, as Heck alleged; she was enrolled in Audible without realizing it, whereas Viveros involved consumers knowingly signing up.

The case later ended in the companies' favour. On 9 July 2026, Judge Chun granted summary judgment for Amazon and Audible and dismissed the lawsuit with prejudice, finding that Heck had produced no evidence supporting the central theory of her claims: the record showed "there is no capacity to redeem Audible titles or begin an Audible subscription using the digital rewards resulting from No-Rush Shipping", Heck could not recall ever using the No-Rush Shipping option or the "Try for $0.00" button, and Audible's trial disclosures complied with California's Automatic Renewal Law.[2] The separate Sherk v. Audible case remained pending before the same court as of December 2025, when an order renoted Audible's motion to dismiss for 2 January 2026.[3]

Lawsuit

[edit | edit source]

In Sherk v. Audible, the plaintiffs claimed that customers were enrolled in Audible memberships without their consent, often without realizing they had been signed up at all.[4] Audible allegedly used personal and billing information already stored in Amazon accounts to facilitate these enrollments and failed to provide explicit written confirmation or conspicuous notice of recurring charges. Many customers only discovered their membership after receiving unexpected billing, and, according to the complaint, Audible made cancellation difficult, with some users continuing to be charged even after attempting to cancel their membership. The lawsuit further alleged that many of these "nonconsensual enrollees" never used Audible's services and that Audible either knew or should have been aware of the widespread problem, given numerous complaints on public forums and consumer watchdog sites. Despite this knowledge, Audible was accused of failing to correct the practice because it generated revenue. Additionally, Audible allegedly restricted refunds, making it difficult for customers to recover payments, and was therefore unjustly enriched by retaining subscription fees from customers who had never agreed to join. The plaintiffs sought restitution and disgorgement of these funds as relief.

In Heck v. Amazon.com Inc., the plaintiff alleged that Amazon and its subsidiary Audible automatically enrolled her in an Audible membership without her knowledge or consent after she selected the "No-Rush Shipping" option for Amazon Prime orders, which provided digital rewards.[1] Heck claimed that she was never informed that redeeming these rewards would result in an Audible trial that would automatically convert into a paid subscription, nor did she receive clear communications about the terms, cancellation policy, or how to opt out. She further alleged that Amazon had exclusive knowledge of this enrollment process and failed to disclose it, creating a situation in which she was charged $14.95 per month for services she did not knowingly subscribe to. The lawsuit asserted violations of California's Consumers Legal Remedies Act (CLRA), the Unfair Competition Law (UCL), and the Auto-Renewal Law (ARL), focusing on non-disclosure, lack of affirmative consent, and the economic harm caused by these automatic charges. Relief sought included damages and restitution for unauthorized subscription fees, highlighting the alleged deceptive practices and failure to obtain informed consent prior to billing. The court granted Amazon's motion for summary judgment in July 2026 and dismissed the case with prejudice.[2]

Consumer response

[edit | edit source]

The complaints describe consumers learning of recurring Audible charges only after the fees appeared on their statements, without an acknowledgment that included Audible's terms, its cancellation policy or instructions on how to cancel the membership.[7] Sherk's complaint stated that Audible knew of numerous complaints on public forums and consumer watchdog sites from customers who said they had been enrolled without agreeing to join, that many of these customers never used Audible's services, and that the company retained the subscription fees.[4]

References

[edit | edit source]
  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 Stutland, Donielle (2025-01-10). "ADVERTISING—W.D. Wash.: Amazon and Audible can't escape class action over auto-enrollment, (Jan 10, 2025)". Vital Law. Archived from the original on 2026-02-23. Retrieved 2025-09-18.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 "Judge tosses Amazon class action over alleged Audible auto-enrollment". Top Class Actions. 2026-07-23. Archived from the original on 2026-07-24. Retrieved 2026-11-01.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 "Grace Sherk v. Audible, Inc. (order renoting motion to dismiss)". Court Listener. 2025-12-18. Archived from the original on 2026-11-01. Retrieved 2026-11-01.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 Sherk, Grace (2025-03-11). "Sherk v. Audible, Inc" (PDF). Class Action. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2025-09-05. Retrieved 2026-11-01.
  5. ↑ 5.0 5.1 "Amazon Audible faces class action over unauthorized subscriptions". Top Class Actions. 2025-04-23. Archived from the original on 2025-08-26. Retrieved 2026-11-01.
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 Chun, John (2025-01-08). "ORDER DENYING MOTION TO DISMISS" (PDF). Courthouse News Service. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2025-01-11. Retrieved 2026-11-01.
  7. ↑ "Heck v. Amazon.com class action complaint (Exhibit A to notice of removal)" (PDF). Court Listener. 2022-05-13. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2026-11-01. Retrieved 2026-11-01.