Forced cloud
Forced cloud makes using a product, or some of its features, depend on an online service controlled by the manufacturer or service provider. This includes functions that could work on the device or the owner's local network. The hardware may still be in working order, but the owner can lose access when the company shuts down a server, changes its software or withdraws permission to connect. Consumer groups call this dependence on software and manufacturers' servers software tethering.[1][2]
For buyers, this can mean a device that stops working before it wears out, a new subscription for features already included in the purchase, or the loss of connections to other equipment. The consequences are not always total failure: a thermostat may still control the heating while losing its phone app, whereas a discontinued smart-home hub may stop operating altogether. What remains usable depends on how the product was designed, not simply on whether its warranty has expired.[1][3][4]
How the dependence works
[edit | edit source]A connected product can have several parts: the physical device, an app, and software running on the manufacturer's servers. Even when the owner is at home, the app may depend on those servers to identify the user, approve a connection or send commands. A product that uses Wi-Fi is therefore not necessarily able to work independently on the home network. Where control depends on a server, even a temporary internet or service outage can interrupt it while the device and local network are working. Consumer Reports' "Longevity by Design" report identified dependence on server approval and the absence of local control as problems that can prevent continued use after support ends.[2]
Local control takes a different approach. A phone, switch or home-automation controller communicates with the device without needing the manufacturer's online service for that action. Cloud features can still be offered alongside it. The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) described local home-automation hubs as a way to reduce dependence on separate manufacturers' apps and servers, while warning that some connected devices still need additional changes before their cloud connections can be removed.[5]
The consumer-protection issue is the loss of functions that could remain available locally, or a dependence on continuing support that was not made clear before purchase. The consumer groups' 2024 letter to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) called for core functions to remain usable without internet access and for support commitments to be disclosed at the point of sale.[1]
Initial setup and periodic permission checks
[edit | edit source]Related online-access requirements also occur in software and subscription services. Microsoft's published requirements stated that Windows 11 Home and Pro for personal use required an internet connection and a Microsoft account during initial setup. This requirement concerned setting up the device, rather than keeping every application permanently connected.[6]
Other products require periodic checks. Videos downloaded via YouTube Premium can normally be played offline for up to 29 days before the device must reconnect; in some countries or regions, the period is 48 hours. The app then checks availability, and a video that is no longer available for offline playback is removed at the next synchronization. These are subscription downloads with continuing access conditions, not unrestricted video files.[7]
Loss of access to other devices and software
[edit | edit source]Owners can lose an automated routine, such as closing a garage door when they lock the front door, because the manufacturer blocks another app's connection. Neither device needs to have physically failed. In 2023, Chamberlain blocked myQ cloud connections used by the home-automation platforms Home Assistant and Homebridge, disrupting routines owners had already set up.[8]
This is a form of vendor lock-in: changing to another app or controller may require extra hardware, a different service or replacement equipment. In its report on connected-product longevity, Consumer Reports recommended letting owners control devices directly on their home network and providing software or tools that keep them useful after their original service ended.[8][2]
Effects on consumers
[edit | edit source]Loss of use and avoidable replacement
[edit | edit source]When a device cannot operate without a particular service, ending that service can also end the useful life of hardware that has not broken. This is discontinuation bricking when the product becomes non-functional, rather than merely losing updates or an optional feature. The Revolv hub stopped working, and Spotify Car Thing stopped working as a Spotify controller, after their services were withdrawn.[4][9]
The resulting cost is not limited to the original purchase. Owners may have to replace equipment and rebuild the arrangements around it, as myQ users faced when trying to restore their home automations. Consumer groups also identified an environmental cost when functioning hardware becomes electronic waste because the software needed to use it is no longer available.[8][1]
New charges after purchase
[edit | edit source]A manufacturer or a new owner of its business can move previously included features behind a subscription. The buyer then has to choose between continuing payments and accepting a product that does less than it did when purchased. Miku's baby-monitor subscription change is a documented example: owners had bought monitoring equipment with breathing and sleep tracking, then faced a monthly charge to keep those functions.[10]
Without a disclosed minimum support period, a one-time price does not tell buyers how long they can rely on a product's online features. Consumer Reports recommended budgeting for support over a disclosed minimum lifetime, including the costs of operating servers and maintaining software, rather than leaving customers to discover the limit after purchase.[2]
Privacy and security
[edit | edit source]A device that routes activity through a company's service can also send information about its use to companies outside the home. The EFF warned that smart-home apps and devices can disclose personal and behavioral information to manufacturers and other companies, and that centralized cloud control creates a target for attackers. Keeping an action local can reduce that exposure, although it does not establish that every app or device has stopped collecting data.[5]
Local operation is not a substitute for security maintenance. Devices and the software controlling them still need appropriate updates, and leaving unsupported equipment connected can create risks. Preserving useful offline functions does not mean an abandoned internet-connected product is safe.[5][2]
Uncertain lifespan and resale
[edit | edit source]A product's physical condition does not reveal how much software support remains. Consumer groups argued that buyers need a minimum support date and a clear account of what will stop working, particularly for expensive products expected to last many years. They also identified resale problems when a second owner cannot obtain the same functions or when a product is sold shortly before its service ends.[1][2]
This affects the practical meaning of ownership. Having the object does not necessarily give its owner the ability to keep using its software, move it to another service or maintain it independently. Consumer Reports' proposed remedies included local control, tools that let owners run replacement software, and access to the information needed for continued support when feasible.[1][2][11]
Documented cases
[edit | edit source]Revolv home-automation hub
[edit | edit source]The Revolv hub was sold for about US$299 to connect and control devices in a smart home. After Nest acquired Revolv, customers were told the app and hub would stop working on 15 May 2016. This went beyond ending new features or security updates: Revolv's subsequent closure notice confirmed that the app and hub no longer worked.[12][4]
The shutdown also disrupted the systems owners had built around the hub. CBC interviewed an owner who used it for lights, motion sensors and home security and had expected it to keep communicating on his home network. Revolv's refund program ended on 31 October 2018.[12][4]
Insteon service loss and paid revival
[edit | edit source]Insteon owners used its hub to connect household lights, outlets, sensors and other smart-home devices. When its servers stopped operating without advance notice in April 2022, owners lost access through the hub's app, the ability to program the hub through it, and cloud connections such as Google and Amazon Alexa. Existing local device operation survived; the shutdown did not make every Insteon switch or sensor unusable.[13]
The cloud service began returning in June 2022 after a group of users acquired Insteon's assets. Owners then faced a subscription to regain hub services, app access, notifications and voice integrations. The announced plans cost US$39.95 for one year or US$69.95 for two years. Restoration was initially incomplete: GearBrain's tests found app control working, but some voice-assistant functions were still unavailable.[13][14]
Miku baby-monitor subscriptions
[edit | edit source]- Main article: Miku charges subscription for previously free features
In 2023, Miku owners were asked to pay US$9.99 a month to keep previously included breathing and sleep tracking. CBS Sacramento interviewed a parent who had bought a Miku Pro monitor in July 2022 and used it to track his son's breathing and sleep. The monitor had a US$399 selling price, although he had bought it at a discount. Without the new subscription, he said, his purchase was essentially a camera.[10]
The change followed Innovative Health Monitoring's acquisition of Miku Inc.'s assets and operations on 15 September. Its notice announced the subscription from 1 October, with app restrictions starting on 2 October.[15]
Owners who declined the subscription retained live video and listening audio when the monitor and viewing device were on the same local Wi-Fi network. Remote viewing, two-way talk and the live breathing waveform were listed among paid functions. Care+ had already been a paid service, and existing subscribers retained their packages. The change reduced the usefulness of an existing purchase without making the entire monitor inoperable.[15]
Chamberlain myQ integrations
[edit | edit source]In 2023, Chamberlain Group blocked what it called unauthorized access to the myQ cloud service used by Home Assistant and Homebridge integrations. Owners lost automated routines such as linking their garage door to a front-door lock or a warning light. Chamberlain said the restriction would improve performance and reliability; Home Assistant objected that owners should be able to access devices they had already paid for.[8][16]
Physical controls, the official app and some authorized integrations remained available, but those options did not replace the blocked home-automation connections. The remaining partners were primarily subscription security services and car manufacturers; the Ring connection was a shortcut to the myQ app. Owners could no longer use the built-in myQ connection with the blocked platforms, and restoring their routines could require additional hardware.[8]
The restrictions also extended to a new generation of garage door openers. In December 2025, The Verge reported that Chamberlain's Security+ 3.0 platform prevented existing aftermarket controllers from providing connections to platforms such as Apple Home and Home Assistant. The new openers received commands wirelessly, instead of through the wired connection those accessories relied on. They also added a separate cloud check to authenticate remotes and accessories, which Chamberlain said was intended to protect users from counterfeits. These changes applied to the new hardware generation, not a remote shutdown of all earlier openers.[17]
Spotify Car Thing
[edit | edit source]- Main article: Spotify Car Thing
Spotify stopped Car Thing from working as a Spotify controller on 9 December 2024. The dashboard controller had reached general sale in February 2022 for about US$90 and relied on a phone, a Spotify Premium subscription and the Spotify service. Owners could therefore lose the use of the purchased controller even while retaining a working phone and an active music subscription.[9][18]
Spotify offered refunds, with reporting on the shutdown giving 14 January 2025 as the deadline to contact support with proof of purchase. The company advised owners to reset and dispose of the device under local electronic-waste guidance. In May 2024, Spotify had declined requests to release the software as open source so owners could extend the device's life.[9][18]
Older Nest Learning Thermostats
[edit | edit source]Google announced that app and connected-feature support for first- and second-generation Nest Learning Thermostats would end on 25 October 2025, including the European second-generation model. Its notice listed the loss of Nest and Google Home app access, remote control, notifications and voice-assistant connections. The link to Nest Protect and its emergency-shutoff feature would also end, along with software and security updates.[3]
The notice said owners could still change temperature and mode on the thermostat itself, and saved schedules would continue to operate. Despite ending the owner-facing cloud features, Google stated the devices would continue sending diagnostic information. It offered eligible users in the US and Canada discounted replacement thermostats, with a deadline of 31 December 2025.[3]
Designs that preserve continued use
[edit | edit source]Cloud dependence can be reduced before a service closes. Consumer Reports' 2025 longevity recommendations called for core functions to work without an internet connection or app, a direct connection between the app and device that does not need approval from the manufacturer's server, and ways to control the device within the home. These design choices can preserve useful operation rather than requiring owners to replace the whole product when a remote service ends.[2]
A local controller does not automatically solve the problem if it still has to contact the manufacturer's servers. The EFF recommended checking whether each device integration uses local or cloud communication. It also warned that moving control into the home can require additional work and that updates to the device's software still need to be maintained.[5]
Where manufacturer support is ending, Consumer Reports recommended providing ways for owners to keep using or repurpose the hardware. These can include software that runs on a home computer instead of the manufacturer's servers, direct phone-to-device connections, and tools that let the hardware run replacement software. Self-hosting, where owners run the service themselves, is one option. Releasing software as open source also requires attention to the licenses and outside components involved. The report recommended planning for these issues while the product is being developed, rather than waiting until the business closed.[2]
The same report called for manufacturers to fund their support promises, disclose the minimum supported lifetime, and plan for a business failure or sale. Those measures address a different problem from local control: keeping promised online services running for the period buyers were told to expect.[2]
Consumer-protection proposals
[edit | edit source]On 5 September 2024, Consumer Reports, U.S. PIRG and other organizations submitted a letter asking the FTC for guidance on software tethering. The requests included clear minimum support commitments, continued core operation when internet access or software support ends, tools for reuse, and protection for independent efforts to make devices work with other systems.[1]
The October 2026 version of Consumer Reports' model Connected Device Longevity Act would require manufacturers to disclose a minimum support date and the functions that will be lost when support ends. The promised support period would have to match reasonable consumer expectations based on the product's nature, price and advertising. Manufacturers would have to notify owners six months before support ends and again on that date. They would also be prohibited from selling, leasing or distributing the product during its final year of guaranteed support. Where feasible and lawful, owners would receive information needed to continue supporting the product.[11]
The model would allow an earlier cutoff only when support became unfeasible because of unforeseeable circumstances beyond the manufacturer's reasonable control, demonstrated in a publicly available written communication to the Attorney General. Examples include insolvency that materially impairs support or the loss of an essential outside service that cannot reasonably be replaced. The model act is a proposal, not enacted law.[11]
See also
[edit | edit source]References
[edit | edit source]- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 Brookman, Justin; Higginbotham, Stacey; Gutterman, Lucas; et al. (2024-09-05). "Letter: Groups call on FTC to develop clear guidance for use of software tethering" (PDF). Consumer Reports. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2024-09-05. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ 2.00 2.01 2.02 2.03 2.04 2.05 2.06 2.07 2.08 2.09 Higginbotham, Stacey (2025-11-19). "Longevity by Design: How to Build Long-lived Connected Products" (PDF). Consumer Reports. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2025-11-19. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 "End of support for Nest Learning Thermostats (1st & 2nd gen)". Google. Archived from the original on 2026-07-12. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 "Revolv is now closed". Revolv. Archived from the original on 2018-09-22. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 5.2 5.3 Budington, Bill (2022-06-30). "Keeping Your Smart Home Secure & Private". Electronic Frontier Foundation. Archived from the original on 2022-06-30. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ "Windows 11 Specs and System Requirements". Microsoft. Archived from the original on 2021-06-24. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ "Watch videos offline with YouTube Premium". Google. Archived from the original on 2026-07-29. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ 8.0 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 Tuohy, Jennifer Pattison (2023-11-07). "This smart garage door controller is no longer very smart". The Verge. Archived from the original on 2026-10-22. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ 9.0 9.1 9.2 Forristal, Lauren (2024-12-09). "Spotify has disabled Car Thing streaming devices". TechCrunch. Archived from the original on 2024-12-10. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ 10.0 10.1 Ming, Kurtis (2023-11-17). "Call Kurtis Investigates: Expensive baby monitor switches to subscription model, parents are ticked". CBS Sacramento. Archived from the original on 2023-11-19. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ 11.0 11.1 11.2 "Connected Device Longevity Act: model legislation" (PDF). Consumer Reports. March 2025. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2026-10-08. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ 12.0 12.1 Chung, Emily (2016-04-06). "Nest's move to stop supporting Revolv smart hub leaves customers with costly 'brick'". CBC News. Archived from the original on 2021-06-14. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ 13.0 13.1 Higginbotham, Stacey (2022-06-07). "Users report Insteon's servers are back online". Stacey on IoT. Archived from the original on 2022-06-09. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ "Insteon Smart Home System is Back in Business – Check Your Hubs". GearBrain. 2022-06-17. Archived from the original on 2022-07-06. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ 15.0 15.1 "Notice of Miku Inc. Acquisition by Innovative Health Monitoring, LLC and Implementation of Subscription Services" (PDF). Innovative Health Monitoring, LLC. 2023-09-15. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2023-10-10. Retrieved 2026-11-15.
- ↑ Schoutsen, Paulus (2023-11-06). "Removal of MyQ integration". Home Assistant. Archived from the original on 2026-10-25. Retrieved 2026-11-15.
- ↑ Tuohy, Jennifer Pattison (2025-12-05). "Chamberlain blocks smart home integrations with its garage door openers — again". The Verge. Archived from the original on 2025-12-05. Retrieved 2026-11-16.
- ↑ 18.0 18.1 Harding, Scharon (2024-05-30). "Spotify won't open-source Car Thing, but starts refund process". Ars Technica. Archived from the original on 2024-05-30. Retrieved 2026-11-16.