Jump to content

User talk:WTFelvemage

Add topic
From Consumer Rights Wiki
Latest comment: 28 October by WTFelvemage in topic url-status field removal

url-status field removal

[edit source]

Unless the field is duplicated elsewhere within the reference, please do not remove it.

  • The CS1 maintenance message serves as a useful notice that one or more references are lacking an archive capture on a page.
  • For references that do have an archive link, removing the url-status will by default treat the original URL as a dead link even when a web page is still live.
  • It's also useful for inexperienced editors who may encounter link rot and wish to update the reference to reflect its current status. "url-status=live" is quite straight-forward in this regard and saves the user from needing to look up the cite web template page.

Thanks for your help on CRW. :) — Sojourna (talk) 05:49, 27 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

@WTFelvemage, have you read this? — Sojourna (talk) 04:48, 28 October 2026 (UTC)Reply
Understood, and thanks for explaining the reasoning. I had been treating the url-status maintenance category as something to clean up, so I will leave the field in place going forward. I also saw the revert on the Bloomberg article, and I will keep author names in references even when they trigger a CS1 message. Thanks for fixing those up, and for the kind words about the work. — WTFelvemage (talk) 12:55, 28 October 2026 (UTC)Reply